Independent vs. Cruise Line Bookings: What's the Difference?

One of the most common questions from Alaska cruise passengers is whether to book their Ketchikan whale watch directly through the ship or with an independent local operator. Here is the data to help you decide.

Booking via Cruise Line

  • Price: Typically $180 - $250+ per person.
  • Group Size: 60 to 150+ passengers.
  • Boat Type: Large water-jet catamarans.
  • Perk: Fixed convenience and perceived "safety."

Perfect for those who value total peace of mind and don't mind larger crowds.

Booking Independently

  • Price: Typically $140 - $175 per person.
  • Group Size: 6 to 12 passengers.
  • Boat Type: Small aluminum rafts or "6-pack" cabin boats.
  • Perk: Intimate experience and closer to the water.

Perfect for photographers and those seeking a personalized, small-group adventure.

Common Myths vs. Reality

Myth: "The cruise ship will only wait for you if you book through them."

Reality: While technically true, independent operators in Ketchikan are deeply integrated with the cruise schedule. They monitor dock arrivals/departures in real-time. Missing a ship would be disastrous for their business reputation. Most offer a "Back-to-Ship" guarantee where they will pay for your transport to the next port if they are late (this has virtually never happened in decades of operation).

Price Comparison Table (2026 Estimates)

Service Cruise Line Price Independent Price Savings
Adult Whale Watch $219 $155 $64 (29%)
Child (Under 12) $169 $115 $54 (32%)
Private Charter Not Offered $800 - $1200 -

How to Book Independently

  1. Check your cruise itinerary for the exact "Port Time."
  2. Look for local operators (like those mentioned in our Shore Excursion Hub).
  3. Ensure the operator is a member of the Ketchikan Visitors Bureau.
  4. Confirm their cancellation policy (most offer full refunds if the ship skips the port due to weather).
View Tours for Princess Guests